ANALYSIS OF SUPREME COURT DECISION NO.556/Pdt.G/2022

Guisepino Bakito Obe, Virgi Faisya Adhazia, Shelby Yoga Pratama, Aprilia Princes Gray, Jeny Aprilia

Abstract


This study examines a breach of contract case involving PT. Hasana Damai Putra and Gregorius Harison S, focusing on the court's role in delivering justice and resolving disputes. The case centers on the defendant's failure to fulfill obligations outlined in a property purchase agreement, resulting in financial losses for the plaintiff. The verdict by the Bekasi District Court deemed the defendant's actions as constituting breach of contract, annulling the agreement and ordering compensation for the plaintiff's damages. Using qualitative normative legal research, this analysis explores factors influencing judicial decisions, including factual assessments, legal interpretations, moral considerations, and social contexts. The court's decision, grounded in plaintiff-provided evidence and meticulous legal analysis, underscores its commitment to upholding contractual obligations and ensuring fairness in legal proceedings. Moreover, it highlights the judiciary's role in protecting individual rights and fostering societal stability. This study underscores the importance of court rulings in providing legal clarity, safeguarding rights, and bolstering public confidence in the legal system. By adhering to principles of justice and applicable laws, court decisions serve as vital tools in resolving disputes, fostering social cohesion, and upholding the rule of law. Therefore, this case serves as a poignant illustration of the judiciary's pivotal role in dispensing justice and maintaining legal order within society.

Keywords:
Breach of contract, Judicial decision-making, Legal analysis, Dispute resolution,Court verdict, Contractual obligations


Full Text:

PDF

References


Hukumonline, T. (2022, October 3). Understanding Default, Consequences, and How to Resolve It.hukumonline.com.https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/unsur-dan-cara-menyelesaikan-w anprestasi-lt62174878376c7/

Imron, M. (2023, December 16). Legal Transparency as a Form of Implementing a Fair and Correct Legal System - Kompasiana.com.COMPASIANA. https://www.kompasiana.com/muchimran228/657d6a3212d50f197467ba92/transparansi-huk um-sebagai-bentuk-terlaksananya-sistem-hukum-yang-adil-dan-benar#google_vignette

Sahroji, A. (n.d.). Types of Judge's Decisions in Civil Law and Examples of Cases.ERA.ID. https://era.id/news/118282/jenis-putusan-hakim#google_vignette

Writer. (2023, November 15). Default in Agreement: Consequences and How to Resolve. Legalnow.https://www.legalnow.co.id/wanprestasi-dalam-perjanjian/#:~:text=Wanprestasi%2 0dalam%20perjanjian%20adalah%20suatu%20tindakan%20atau%20perilaku,kewajibannya

%20sesuai%20dengan%20kesepakatan%20yang%20telah%20disepakati%20sebelumnya.

Sitanggang, D. D. K. P. (2022, August 23). Default is Article, Legal Basis, and Examples. Detikjabar.

https://www.detik.com/jabar/bisnis/d-6249594/wanprestasi-adalah-pasal-dasar-hukum-dan-co ntohnya Steven Tenny; Janelle M. Brannan; Grace D. Brannan. Qualitative Study. (National Library of Medicine, September 2022) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470395/#:~:text=Qualitative%20research%20is%2 0a%20type,well%20as%20further%20investigate%20and

Admin. (2023, August 1). The Role of Judges in the Judicial System: Independent and Fair Law Enforcement. FACULTY OF LAW | Innovative, Personality and Independent.https://hukum.uma.ac.id/2023/07/17/peran-hakim-dalam-sistem-peradilan-peneg ak-hukum-yang-independen-dan-adil/

Fajar, M. a. A. (n.d.). Article 28D Paragraphs 1 - 4 of the 1945 Constitution | SNACKING. https://www.bercamilan.com/uud-1945/pasal-28d.html

Mayor Chk Salis A.W., S.H. SOME TERMS IN THE JUDGE'S RULING. (n.d.).

https://dilmil-yogyakarta.go.id/beberapa-istilah-dalam-putusan-hakim/

Admin. (2023a, May 27). Understanding the Judicial Process: Stages, Principles, and Importance in the Legal System.

https://jayalawyer.com/memahami-proses-peradilan-tahapan-prinsip-dan-pentingnya-dalam-s istem-hukum/

Isnantiana, Nur. (2017). Judges' Legal Reasoning in Making Case Decisions in Court. IN ISLAM. 18. 41. 10.30595/islamadina. v18i2.1920.

Kristina. (2021, October 19). Sounds and Explanation of Article 27 Paragraph 1 of the 1945 Constitution, Do Students Know?I detect.

https://www.detik.com/edu/detikpedia/d-5773438/bunyi-dan-penjelasan-pasal-27-ayat-1-uud- 1945-siswa-sudah-tahu




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33021/ph.v9i2.5204

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2024 Problematika Hukum



View My Stats

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.